Time to Sing a New Song: Thoughts One Year After a Breast Cancer Diagnosis


When you’ve had cancer, your emotional taste buds change everything. A sunset is more brilliant, smells of flowers are magnified, music touches the heart more. So when my daughter sent me a WhatsApp in December that she was in the delivery room with another one of my daughters in a hospital in the Negev, I burst into tears. We have, bli ayin hara, many grandchildren, and I’ve attended some of those births, but I never cried before upon hearing that a daughter was in the delivery room. Yet here I was sobbing uncontrollably.

And I knew why. I didn’t cry for myself throughout the year of my diagnosis, chemotherapy, operation or radiation. But for any milestone or emotional occasion since then, the floodgates open—this time especially, because we were celebrating a new life and I’m still here.

When I got my diagnosis, I didn’t go into a tailspin. I thought, Thank God, I have healthy children and grandchildren, a loving husband, and I’ve done a lot of good things in my life. I’ve had many students, written meaningful articles and plays, and directed theater troupes and projects that brought joy and healing to others. If Hashem decides I’ve done enough, that’s His call.

I was in the middle of producing and directing a revival of a Biblical musical by our Raise Your Spirits Theatre troupe called Ruth & Naomi in the Fields of Bethlehem, a show, appropriately, about chesed (kindness). The cast, crew and stage moms all stepped up to the plate when they learned about my illness; they, along with my family and close friends, became a loving support group. Every time I walked through the door of the Efrat Community Center where we held our rehearsals, my cancer disappeared. On some days, during the chemo treatment period, when I was exhausted, the lead actresses would rehearse in my living room with me reclining on the couch. Once, I fell asleep in the middle of rehearsal and they tiptoed out quietly.

It was important to me to tell the cast and crew about my illness personally. I didn’t want the children in the cast to hear through the grapevine at school. And I wanted them to see me smiling and functioning, even when it became clear that my beret was covering a bald head. They will all have challenges in their lives, I thought, and I want them to see that someone with a difficult challenge can get through it with cheerfulness and faith.

When my hair began to fall out, I asked a friend to photograph me getting my head shaved at the local beauty shop. Then we took selfies, including one with me looking cool in a fedora and sunglasses.

I got a big infusion of faith from one of our choreographers, an Italian dance and theater professional who was studying, along with her Italian artist-performer husband, to convert to Judaism. Her post-conversion name is Emuna Bracha—Faith and Blessing. She would talk to me about God’s goodness and the fact that He always has a plan, which I knew, but it meant so much to me to hear it from her. The day she and her husband completed their conversion and got married l’halachah was a chemo day for me. A cast member drove me to the wedding. I sat on the side, utterly exhausted, but at one point I took two belly-dancing belts, went into the dancing circle, tied one around Emuna Bracha’s hips, the other around mine, and for five minutes I danced with her. It was my badge of courage. I had decided there was no way I was going to miss the opportunity to bring joy to this particular bride. Afterward, I had to sit down and breathe heavily for ten minutes, but it was worth it.

I discovered the sisterhood (and brotherhood) of cancer, and I also began quietly giving support to others—including a woman in our community who had told no one but her immediate family and me about her illness. I discovered scores of people, in hospitals and elsewhere, who are humbly doing chesed for patients, without fanfare. At one point, I had my Na’na Playback Theater (improv) actresses act out some of my harrowing stories for me, to help me heal. I felt all the love and support I had given them through the years come flooding back to me.

They will all have challenges in their lives, I thought, and I want them to see that someone with a difficult challenge can get through it with cheerfulness and faith.

There were crises and hardships along the way, beyond the scope of this essay; but no one’s cancer story is simple and every patient could write her own book.

Sometimes I wanted to be alone, in the quiet. But I also discovered the value of bikur cholim (visiting the sick). In these days of social media posts, e-mails and texts—and I truly cherished every one of those comforting messages—it was special when friends paused their busy lives or overcame their discomfort and actually came to visit. During a particularly difficult time for me, one friend came on Purim with her daughter, who told her mother afterwards, “I understand now the impact of bikur cholim. When we walked through the door, Toby could not lift her head off the couch. By the time we left, she was sitting up and laughing.”

I treasured every gift—mugs with messages, flowers and plants, books of poetry, paintings, songs, home-made ice cream and gourmet coffee. One neighbor sent over a pot of chicken soup every Friday night for months. After my chemo treatment ended, I told her she could stop. She said, “I’ll wait for the operation.” After the operation, she said, “I’ll wait until after the radiation.” After the radiation, I said to her with a smile, “You know, I have to take pills for five years now,” but finally released her from her incredible chesed.

Dr. Naomi Baum, a psychologist friend of mine, had written a book, Life Unexpected, about her own journey with breast cancer. It became my guidebook. Fern Reiss, another friend, had written The Breast Cancer Checklist, which proved invaluable.

I discovered the power of prayer. My own prayer included the reciting of Psalm 100 every day—Mizmor L’Todah. When my operation went well and recuperation was quick, I felt that the davening of all my family and friends, actresses and fellow students in the Torah class I attend at Matan, had shaken the heavens.

A young neighbor told me that I was her “hero” because whenever she saw me I was smiling. I’m not a hero, I told her. Heroes are individuals who go beyond their capabilities. But this is the only way I know how to live.

The radiation, which I had heard could be unpleasant, became for me a “high,” due to the words of a friend who had battled breast cancer five years earlier. She told me, “Radiation was a spiritual experience for me. Every time I got on that table, I imagined God coming down and zapping the bad stuff out of me.” Her comment influenced me to the point that I would get on the table and use that time to communicate with Hashem. It was our special time together.

My husband was with me during every chemo treatment, but I drove myself to radiation alone. My role model was my mother’s cousin. A breast cancer patient some thirty years earlier, she had driven herself to radiation and afterward to her teaching job. I’d weave along the winding Wallaje bypass road from Gush Etzion to Hadassah every morning at 6:15 am, have my telepathic talk with God, grab a morning latte in the lobby and drive home.

At the end of twenty treatments, I felt a letdown, the end of my spiritual journey, but of course, the journey never ends; it just changes. I had many wonderful shlichim—messengers of God. Holistic healers helped me weather the storm with their dedication, skills and wisdom. I had a female breast surgeon, plastic surgeon and oncologist at Hadassah, and I felt the extra sensitivity of females treating females. I also had an exceptionally compassionate male ENT surgeon who thought they would have to open my chest to take out my right (non-cancerous) thyroid lobe due to its location (a late-discovered complication that blocked part of my airway), but he managed to do it through the throat. When I told him later, “They call you a magician,” he said modestly, “I just got lucky.” I said, “I had a lot of people praying for me.” He said, “I also pray before every operation.”

“I’m not a hero,” I told her. “Heroes are individuals who go beyond their capabilities. But this is the only way I know how to live.”

The secretaries in the local health fund smoothed the bureaucratic process for me. One of them called me at home one day and said, “I met your husband and asked how you are and he said you’re a little weak; I just wanted to check up on you.” The secretary at an HMO? Only in Israel.

I experienced the deep love and devotion of my husband and children. Most of our children are married and scattered throughout the country with children of their own and busy lives, but they were there for me. After I woke up from my operation, I kept repeating to the two who were present (on rotation), “I have the most wonderful children in the world.” I heard my daughter whisper to my son, “It must be the anesthesia.” “It’s not the anesthesia,” I said. “I know I’m repeating myself. But I want to say it again and again.”

During the treatment and operation period, my creativity had become blocked. I only had patience to read mysteries and watch sitcoms, stand-up humor (thank you, Jeanne Robertson) and dramas. (I discovered that it’s not wise to watch medical shows when one has cancer.) The moment the radiation was over, I felt a burst of new creative energy, more ideas for books and theater projects than I could implement in a lifetime. I also discovered a new sense of gratitude. Every night, before I go to sleep, I say out loud, “Thank you Hashem for my husband, my children, my grandchildren, my friends, my health, for the roof over my head, this warm bed, the food I eat, the clothes I wear, for the fact that I have the opportunity to do creative things. . . .”

I had received my diagnosis on November 28, 2016, which corresponded to the twenty-seventh day of Cheshvan. In 2017, it fell on November 16. Thirteen years earlier I had begun, with a friend, Yael Valier, to collect materials about the anusim (conversos) of Spain, with the goal of producing a musical theater project. My new idea was to expand that concept and produce a show about the missing and hidden Jews through the centuries—not just from Spain, but also from the Ten Lost Tribes, like the Bnei Menashe community of India and Jews from Poland, China, Indonesia, Africa and elsewhere who were discovering their faith. On November 16, 2017, one year from the day I was diagnosed, eighty immigrants from the Bnei Menashe community were brought to Israel by the Shavei Israel organization. I knew I wanted to be there.

I drove to the airport and saw them come through the sliding doors—men and women and children, older people in wheelchairs, some who were reuniting with family members after seventeen years. People hugged, sang, danced and cried. I noticed a young woman with a baby girl in a sling. I asked her what the child’s name was. She said, “Chadasha”—“New.” I asked her what her own name was. She said, “Shira”—“Song.” Together,  “a new song.”

And I knew then that the name of the show I would write would be A New Song—Melodies and Monologues of the Missing Jews.

And I knew why I had been drawn to this particular event on this particular day.

To remind me that, one year after my diagnosis, I was ready to sing a new song.

Photo: Susan Handelman

Toby Klein Greenwald, a regular contributor to Jewish Action, is a journalist, playwright, poet, teacher, and the artistic director of a number of theater companies. She is the recent recipient of the Lifetime Achievement award from Atara – The Association for Torah and the Arts for “dedication and contributions in creative education, journalism, theatre and the performing arts worldwide.”

This article was featured in the Summer 2018 issue of Jewish Action.
We'd like to hear what you think about this article. Post a comment or email us at